The Key West Cakes Story

Key West Cakes was founded in 2001 by Paulie & Steven as a specialty cake bakery dedicated to equal parts creativity, presentation, and flavor. Starting small, with a small kitchen and tight-knit group of cake artists, Key West Cakes began in Paul's home kitchen. The rest has been a fairy tale success. Key West Cakes and the entire operation grew. In 2010, Key West Cakes moved into their headquarters, custom bakery on historic White Street in downtown Key West.

“The Knot”

Key West Cakes has been awarded the selectively prestigious "Best in Weddings" designation by premier wedding planning resource The Knot. The Knot's "Best in Weddings" designation is voted on internationally by brides having Key West weddings. See for yourself here. 



Southernmost Award-Winning Speciality Bakery in USA



Do you offer tastings?

We offer one complimentary tasting that will serve an estimate of 2 to 3 people.

When are you available for a tasting?

All tastings are by appointment only. Call us today to set an appointment! We offer these Monday - Friday between the hours of 12pm - 5:30pm. 

Do you require a deposit for wedding cakes?

Yes, a 50% non-refundable deposit is required to get the cake of your dreams started. This secures the date with us, but you can still alter your order as needed after a deposit is taken.

Can you match a color?

We do our best. Please provide swatches with any information of colors that we will need to make your cake. We try to match the colors as close as possible, but cannot guarantee an exact match of any color.

Do you provide cake toppers?

We don’t provide any traditional cake toppers. Those will need to be purchased separately and then provided to use. However, we do make custom toppers both and non-edible (bows, beach chairs, fruit and many more). Please contact us with any specific questions or concerns.

Do you provide real flowers?

All flowers may be ordered through your florist and delivered to us.

For your own Key West Cake, call for consultation and tasting 305-296-4162.

Still have more questions?

Feel free to contact us or stop in and say hi.